|Marty the Moth||1||June 26, 2016||London, England||Won at Conquest: UK||98|
|The Miz||1||October 2, 2016||Richmond, VA||Won at Hostile Makeover||35|
|Marty Scurll||1||November 6, 2016||Sacramento, CA||Won at Unbreakable|
This was Fatal four way match also involving Darren Young & Bull Dempsey.
|Aiden English||1||Jaunary 11, 2018||Orlando, FL||Won on Live! on Fight Network||108|
|Jay Lethal||1||April 29, 2018||New Orleans, LA||Won at Scurll's Spring Break II|
This was a Fatal four way match also involving Braun Strowman & Drew Galloway
List of reign lengthsEdit
- As of October 16, 2018.
|Wrestler||Days Held||Date Won||Date Lost|
|Marty Scurll||431||November 6, 2016||Jaunary 11, 2018|
|Aiden English||108||Jaunary 11, 2018||April 29, 2018|
|Marty the Moth||98||June 26, 2016||October 2, 2016|
|The Miz||35||October 2, 2016||November 6, 2016|
|Jay Lethal||170+||April 29, 2018||Current Champion|